Good One

Play trailer

2:22

Good One

R

2024

1h 30m

Drama

Play Trailer

Watchlist

Watchlist

Tomatometer

Popcornmeter

98%

Tomatometer

122 Reviews

73%

Popcornmeter

100+ Ratings

In India Donaldson's insightful, piercing debut, 17-year-old Sam (Lily Collias) embarks on a three-day backpacking trip in the Catskills with her dad, Chris (James Le Gros) and his oldest friend, Matt (Danny McCarthy). As the two men quickly settle into a gently quarrelsome brotherly dynamic, airing long-held grievances, Sam, wise beyond her years, attempts to mediate. But when lines are crossed and Sam's trust is betrayed, tensions reach a fever pitch, as Sam struggles with her dad's emotional limitations and experiences the universal moment when the parental bond is tested. Selected in both Sundance and Cannes' Directors' Fortnight, Good One is an emotionally expansive work that probes the limits of familial trust, understanding, and ultimately, forgiveness.

Watch on Fandango at Home

Stream Now

Critics Consensus

A beautifully acted depiction of being caught between a rock and a hard place, Good One confronts difficult emotions and yields a striking feature debut for writer-director India Donaldson.

Read Critics Reviews

Tom Charity

Sight & Sound

Nov 4

Good One is a backwoods horror film after all – even if there’s no physical violence. It’s a horror film in which nothing much happens, but for Sam the world is turned upside down.

Go to Full Review

Wendy Ide

Observer (UK)

Oct 8

Donaldson, who, as the daughter of director Roger Donaldson (Cocktail, Dante’s Peak) grew up around the film industry, is no mere imitator. This is a supremely accomplished and confident work. Her framing is immaculate.

Go to Full Review

Adam Nayman

Toronto Star

06/17/2025

Good One isn’t quite skilful or original enough to transcend its schematic structure. But it’s still a very fine piece of work, starting with its lovely, richly textured cinematography (by Wilson Cameron) through its precisely modulated ensemble acting.

Go to Full Review

David Bax

Battleship Pretension

Jan 7

An early clue that Good One is more than a light, humanistic dramedy comes in the form of Celia Hollander’s sad, harp-driven score.

Go to Full Review

Pedro Gallego

Espinof

Dec 15

4/5

Its coming-of-age story is careful, yet also appropriately sharp. [Full review in Spanish]

Go to Full Review

Olivia Popp

Purple Hour

Nov 18

Good One is a deadly microcosm: we no longer begin to wonder why men everywhere might act the way they do. Instead, we must sit with the dark reality that we, as a society, simply haven’t broken the cycle.

Go to Full Review

Read all reviews

Babsallday U

09/03/2024

I dont know why this is a movie no real point taken! Hollywood bites these days. Im serious. This movie was a walk in the park although wonderful, absolutely not mind bending.

See more

Brenda

09/01/2024

It was very slow. And did not have an ending. I felt like I wasted time on this one.

See more

David

08/30/2024

it really good in it's own sense. hard to describe

See more

Ronald B

08/27/2024

Well written dialogue, authentic relationships, beautiful nature photography.

See more

Robert

08/21/2024

Great story about the relationship between fathers and daughters. Very realistic situations, and the acting was top notch.

See more

Chris L

@Christoph2000 Apr 21

This quiet slice of uncomfortable realism set in the beautiful Catskills should be a breakthrough for Lily Collias. 90 minutes is the perfect runtime as it's a bar for a first time filmmaker to make an independent socially relevant piece like this and disallow boredom from setting in, yet India Donaldson comfortably clears it - the movie is perfectly paced. What's it like for a headstrong, emotionally mature yet still vulnerable young woman to face a stark reckoning with her father's gender tribalism and unconscious misogyny? Watch and find out. Long live independent cinema and may its voices continue to reach audiences far and wide as the great Robert Redford intended. I'm not prepared to ignore the soundtrack problem though - not every frame was assaulted by grating harp la di da sounds, but too many were. It's often best to let the vast wilderness speak for itself. It's no secret the art of conversation has been decimated in this cursed digital age: here's how not to approach it.

See more

Read all reviews

Read More

Read Less

WRITE A REVIEW

EDIT REVIEW

POST RATING

India Donaldson

Director

Lily Collias

Sam

James Le Gros

Chris

Danny McCarthy

Matt

Sumaya Bouhbal

Jessie

India Donaldson

Screenwriter

Aftersun

95%

82%

Aftersun

Watchlist

TRAILER

for Aftersun

A Thousand and One

97%

85%

A Thousand and One

Watchlist

TRAILER

for A Thousand and One

Exhibiting Forgiveness

95%

92%

Exhibiting Forgiveness

Watchlist

TRAILER

for Exhibiting Forgiveness

Nomadland

93%

82%

Nomadland

Watchlist

TRAILER

for Nomadland

Marriage Story

95%

85%

Marriage Story

Watchlist

TRAILER

for Marriage Story

Discover more movies and TV shows.

View More

Good One: Trailer 1

2:22

View more videos

View more photos

Synopsis

In India Donaldson's insightful, piercing debut, 17-year-old Sam (Lily Collias) embarks on a three-day backpacking trip in the Catskills with her dad, Chris (James Le Gros) and his oldest friend, Matt (Danny McCarthy). As the two men quickly settle into a gently quarrelsome brotherly dynamic, airing long-held grievances, Sam, wise beyond her years, attempts to mediate. But when lines are crossed and Sam's trust is betrayed, tensions reach a fever pitch, as Sam struggles with her dad's emotional limitations and experiences the universal moment when the parental bond is tested. Selected in both Sundance and Cannes' Directors' Fortnight, Good One is an emotionally expansive work that probes the limits of familial trust, understanding, and ultimately, forgiveness.

Director: India Donaldson
Producer: Diana Irvine, Graham Mason, Wilson Cameron, India Donaldson
Screenwriter: India Donaldson
Distributor: Metrograph Pictures
Production Co: Smudge Films, International Pigeon Production, Baird Street Pictures, Tinygiant
Rating: R (Language)
Genre: Drama
Original Language: English
Release Date (Theaters): Aug 9, 2024, Limited
Runtime: 1h 30m