The Horse Whisperer

Audience Reviews

View More

Robert P @Superbad Oct 7, 2026 The Horse Whisperer is a *3.5* star Movie! See more

Keith W @Keith166 Aug 24, 2026 An average rating for an average film. It was just about ok. The best part was that Kirstin Scott-Thomas preferred the more rugged Sam Neill to the far too smooth Robert Redford{ he is definitely too good to be true. And the scenery was lovely. See more

Reni B @Artistrenivbifamo Apr 28, 2026 I visit Sometimes Horses sport Events and I studied them. This Film is so true und a good advice See more

thiago S @Thiagostone Mar 7, 2026 Filme fraco, o roteiro é fraco, as cenas são fracas, a história é fraca, o elenco é fraco, e ninguém ajuda a melhorar o filme, os personagens são fracos, e o filme deveria ter cenas bem melhores e relevantes, para fazer o filme ser bom See more

PERCY B @P.BADINAGE Nov 12, 2025 It would have been a better movie much shorter. Almost 3 hrs a movie has to be really good to be that long and this isn't. I love Robert Redford personally but he no screen chemistry at all with Kristin Scott Thomas. It could be the characters but RR doesn't emote emotion and that really hurt this story because other than fixing the horse, the story here is the attraction between RR and KST and it just doesn't work. Perhaps lop off a hour and it would have more of a chance. See more

Matthew D @OceanSage Sep 30, 2025 A very gentle and patient film that gives every character moments of heartfelt depth. Director Robert Redford’s neo-Western drama The Horse Whisperer (1998) is surprisingly engaging and moving. Redford directs these incredibly intimate and vulnerable performances from his stellar ensemble that I found very touching. He lets his actors and actresses feel real and conflicted about their raw emotions. It’s a beautiful film with vast grassy plains, wavy hills, and tons of pretty horses. Redford’s direction starts off with an exciting and horrifying accident that genuinely shocked me. Then he takes his time with appreciating each person and horse’s trauma with how best to help them heal. It’s a very mature, adult, and nurturing picture. I just think it’s lovely. It’s precious to see Redford in his favorite horse ranch environment. You can tell that The Horse Whisperer was a very important passion project for him. Writers Richard LaGravenese and Eric Roth take care with each person and their individual traumas, frustrations, anger, isolation, loneliness, romance, humor, regrets, fears, and hope. The Horse Whisperer takes everything very seriously and earnestly for a mature tone. I really felt empathy for each of their pains. It will make you want to consider those around you more tenderly with empathy and patience, much like Robert Redford patiently cares for this wounded horse Pilgrim. Robert Redford is very cool, calm, and tender as the affectionate and tough horse rancher Tom Booker. He’s an understated hero in a way that Redford excels at portraying. He’s very handsome, funny, and likable, but it’s his gentle manner with helping Scarlett Johansson’s little girl heal her trauma that is the sweetest stuff. Scarlett Johansson is adorable, moving, natural, and powerful as the injured little heroine Grace MacLean. She comes across as a real teenage girl who is hurting inside and frustrated with her mother’s high standards and lack of empathy. This is honestly one of her greatest performances. I love her scenes with her horse Pilgrim. Kate Bosworth cameos as Grace’s best friend Judith, who perishes in the shocking opening accident. Kristin Scott Thomas is fantastic as the heartbreaking mother Annie MacLean, who is having trouble opening up and reaching out to her daughter. She feels very harsh, then opens up as she gets to know Redford. Kristin Scott Thomas is a very versatile actress, and it’s nice to see her so expressive. Sam Neill is excellent in his brief role as her husband Robert MacLean, who really cares about his daughter. He’s very natural and sincere. Dianne Wiest is pleasant as the sweet rancher’s wife Dianne Booker. It’s fun when she’s stern with her husband that Chris Cooper plays so endearingly as Frank Booker. They’re a fun pair of supporting characters. Cherry Jones is excellent as the concerned horse caretaker Liz Hammond, who thinks the horse Pilgrim should just be put down. Ty Hillman is great as the fun loving rancher kid Joe Booker. Editors Freeman A. Davies, Hank Corwin, and Tom Rolf cut these loving montages of horse riding, horses galloping themselves, horse washing, cattle roping, and cattle branding. They linger on the heartfelt emotional scenes and allow us to really get to know the characters. Cinematographer Robert Richardson’s stunning wide shots of the ranch grasslands are something else. Composers Gwil Owen and Thomas Newman’s film score is amazing with a gentle style that swells with emotion. In all, The Horse Whisperer had me enthralling even for a massive 169 minutes. Scarlett Johansson, Kristin Scott Thomas, and Robert Redford are fantastic. See more

Read all reviews

The Horse Whisperer

My Rating

Read More Read Less WRITE A REVIEW EDIT REVIEW POST RATING