The Conspirator

Audience Reviews

View More

Jose O @RT02487765 May 8 Educational tool to explore key aspects of human rights explored in "The Conspirator". The right to a fair trial, a deeply resonant element given life through the film's portrayal of Mary Surratt’s experience in the courtroom. We watch closely as her trial unfolds, shaped by the powerful forces of political agendas and a pervasive atmosphere of distrust, making viewers question the justice system’s neutrality. The courtroom scenes reveal a military commission taking the place of a civil court, which strips away several vital protections, such as the chance to be judged by an unbiased jury and adhering to strict evidence standards. This setup serves to underline the delicate balance between public safety and personal freedoms, particularly during national crises. By showing what the defense is up against, the film nudges the audience to ponder the real-world implications when essential legal processes are sacrificed for the sake of expediency. See more Parker S @RT96054568 Apr 28 While many concerns about this movie are about the talkative courtroom drama aspects of this film, I believe that these decisions were prudent from the film's makers. This story tells the very real experience of Mary Surrat, and goes to great lengths to make it feel authentic and grounded - even convincing me of her innocence. Her performance humanized the character for me, and made me understand her side of the story. She is a compelling character, and Robin Wright portrays her as a woman of integrity throughout. James McAvoy also steals the show as he helps the audience to empathize with both sides during this film. The legal elements such as Habeus Corpus are also made to be very digestible for audiences with no prior legal knowledge or experience. Overall I thought the execution was wonderful, and walked out of the experience with a new perspective. Would absolutely watch again!| See more Garruk F @RT52531129 Apr 28 I think this film was a little... flat. You have an A-list cast, a pivotal moment to bounce from in American history, and they kind of just... made it a film where they only talk to each other. Now granted, portions of the American Justice system like Habeus Corpus is not exactly known by your average American, but it really wasn't explained to an audience in case they didn't know. It's like they explained every facet of the film that mattered except their one out. It was brought up at the climax of the film as their "main coup de gras", but then not only did it do absolutely nothing, but then the guilty verdict came anyways for Surrat. I love sitting through a 2+ hour film, watching the protagonist fight tooth and nail for a cause they don't really believe in, just for the whole thing to have been for nothing. The film is fair with her representation, and she needed to be portrayed as guilty to preserve history, so I do believe it should have ended in such a manner. See more Zoe W @RT88465267 Apr 18 I personally really enjoyed this movie. I felt that it did a good job of tackling a specific legal principle. That one being the right to due process vs. a military tribunal and whether or not the government can take away someone’s right to trial by jury when the nation's security is at risk. We know that in Ex parte Milligan, ruled that the government cannot just forgo a civilian trial for a tribunal one when civilian trials are perfectly operational. However, the government turns a blind eye to that principle and decides to try Mary in a military tribunal. So essentially due to the high nature of Mary Sutton’s case, the court’s decided to forgo her constitutional rights See more Katie C @RT09835492 Apr 5 I found this film surprisingly engaging. I am usually not a fan of long dramas, but The Conspirator managed to keep my attention for most of the time. The actors all did a great job, particularly James McAvoy and Robin Wright. The sets and clothing seemed appropriate for the time period, at least in my nonexpert opinion. Overall, I think the film did a good job of transporting the audience to the time period. I would say that is a worth a watch. The military court Mary Surratt was subjected to was illegal, unjust, and unconstitutional. The United States government should have never orchestrated such an unfair ruling. This movie definitely shown light on some extremely corrupt instances in our government's past. President Johnson and the Secretary of War are especially guilty. I believe the movie portrayed Mary fairly, but I don't believe she deserved the death penalty. I don't think Mary was entirely innocent, but her death was unjust. See more Nathen P @RT38256541 Apr 2 This is a movie that is about the trial of Mary Surratt being convicted of Conspiracy to the assassination of Lincoln. The beginning felt a little too long and slow, it felt that it could have been sped up faster, but the reason that it felt slow could be of all the necessary information for place setting for the movie. The Military Tribunal that was the court is kind of ironic because the Union saw the entire US as the US as the Confederacy saw two different countries, and with Tribunals being held against defendants are usually of people from another country, and this Military Tribunal was heavily outweighing Mrs. Surratt in the way she was treated, no sunlight, barely any food, and no life besides jail and court. In the end I was hoping the son would burst through the courtroom doors to save his mother, but this isn't Disney, rather the real account of what happened. This is probably the saddest part of the movie, as because he didn't show, she was put to death by hanging in public. See more Read all reviews

The Conspirator

My Rating

Read More Read Less WRITE A REVIEW EDIT REVIEW POST RATING